Painting your home or office often raises a common question: is Benjamin Moore more expensive than Sherwin Williams? The answer isn’t as simple as a single number. Prices vary depending on the product line, coverage needs, and quality of finish.
In this guide, we’ll break down the costs, compare premium and budget options, and explore which paint provides the best value for your money. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of both brands, helping you make an informed decision for your next painting project. Whether you’re a DIY enthusiast or hiring professionals, this comparison will save time, money, and headaches.
Quick Answer: Is Benjamin Moore More Expensive Than Sherwin Williams?
Yes, Benjamin Moore is generally more expensive than Sherwin Williams, especially when comparing premium product lines. On average, a gallon of Benjamin Moore paint costs slightly more, with high-end lines like Aura reaching $80–$90 per gallon, while Sherwin Williams premium lines like Emerald typically range from $60–$80.
However, the difference isn’t always significant. Some mid-range or budget paints from Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are very close in price. The true cost often depends on coverage, the number of coats required, and the type of project. Understanding these factors will help you determine which brand offers better value for your specific needs.
Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin Williams – Price Comparison (2025 Data)
When comparing Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams, price is one of the first factors buyers consider. While Benjamin Moore generally comes with a slightly higher price tag, the difference varies depending on the specific product line. On average, a gallon of Benjamin Moore paint costs around $57, whereas Sherwin Williams averages about $53 per gallon.
Average Price Per Gallon
-
Benjamin Moore: ~$57 per gallon on average
-
Sherwin Williams: ~$53 per gallon on average
This difference becomes more noticeable in premium lines, but mid-range and budget paints can be very close in price.
Price Range by Product Line
| Brand | Budget Line | Mid-Range | Premium Line | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Coronado ($25+) | Ultra Spec 500 ($38+) | Aura ($80–$90) | ~$25–$90 |
| Sherwin Williams | Budget lines ($25–$26) | SuperPaint (~$64) | Emerald/Duration ($60–$80+) | ~$25–$80+ |
Why Benjamin Moore Tends to Cost More
Benjamin Moore paints are known for their high pigment content, smoother finish, and better consistency. These qualities can reduce the number of coats needed, which might offset the higher upfront cost. Sherwin Williams offers excellent mid-range and premium paints at slightly lower prices but may require more coats in some cases.
Value Comparison – Which Paint Is Worth Your Money?
When deciding between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams, the price per gallon tells only part of the story. True value depends on coverage, finish, and how much paint you actually need for your project.
Coverage & Coats Needed
Benjamin Moore paints often provide better coverage, meaning fewer coats are required. For example, premium lines like Aura can cover more area in a single coat, reducing labor and overall paint usage. Sherwin Williams paints, while high quality, sometimes need extra coats to achieve the same level of coverage, especially in lighter or more vibrant colors.
Durability & Finish Quality
The finish of Benjamin Moore paint is often smoother, richer, and more consistent, which makes walls look professional and polished. Sherwin Williams also produces durable paints, particularly in lines like Emerald or Duration, but the finish may require more careful application to avoid streaks or uneven coverage.
Long-Term Cost Efficiency
Although Benjamin Moore has a higher upfront cost, the fewer coats and superior coverage can lower total project expenses. Sherwin Williams may be cheaper per gallon, but the extra coats, labor, or touch-ups could offset initial savings. Evaluating total value rather than just price helps you make the most cost-effective decision for your project.
Pros & Cons of Each Brand (At a Glance)
Here’s a quick overview of the main advantages and drawbacks of Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams to help you make an informed choice.
Benjamin Moore
Pros:
- Excellent coverage, often requiring fewer coats
- Smooth, rich finish with professional appearance
- Long-lasting color retention
- High-quality premium lines like Aura and Regal
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost per gallon
- Fewer retail locations compared to Sherwin Williams
- Limited budget line options
Sherwin Williams
Pros:
- Wide range of product lines at varying price points
- Frequent sales and promotions make it budget-friendly
- Durable premium paints like Emerald and Duration
- More accessible stores nationwide
Cons:
- Some mid-range lines may require additional coats
- Finish may be slightly less consistent compared to Benjamin Moore
- Higher labor and paint usage in some projects
Which Paint Should You Choose? (Decision Guide)
Choosing between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams depends on your priorities: budget, coverage, and the type of project. If you value superior coverage and a smooth, professional finish, Benjamin Moore premium lines like Aura or Regal are worth the higher price. They often reduce the number of coats needed, which can save time and labor costs.
Sherwin Williams is a solid choice for those looking for a wide variety of paints at different price points. Frequent sales and promotions make it more accessible for budget-conscious buyers, while premium lines like Emerald or Duration deliver excellent durability.
| Priority | Recommended Brand | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Best coverage & premium finish | Benjamin Moore | Fewer coats, professional results |
| Budget-friendly & variety | Sherwin Williams | Frequent sales, wide product range |
| DIY beginners | Sherwin Williams | Easier accessibility, good mid-range options |
| Long-term project value | Benjamin Moore | High-quality finish may save labor & paint |
By considering your project type, coverage needs, and budget, you can select the paint brand that provides the best overall value.
Final Verdict: Is Benjamin Moore More Expensive Than Sherwin Williams?
In summary, Benjamin Moore is generally more expensive than Sherwin Williams, particularly in premium lines like Aura and Regal. However, the higher upfront cost often comes with better coverage, fewer coats, and a smoother, more professional finish, which can save time and labor in the long run.
Sherwin Williams offers a wide range of paints at varying price points, with frequent sales and promotions making it a budget-friendly option. While some mid-range lines may require additional coats, the brand remains accessible and reliable for both DIYers and professionals.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your project priorities: choose Benjamin Moore for premium coverage and finish, or Sherwin Williams for variety, accessibility, and cost-conscious projects.
FAQs – Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin Williams
1. Is Benjamin Moore really better quality?
Ans: Yes, Benjamin Moore paints, especially premium lines like Aura, often provide smoother finishes, richer colors, and better coverage compared to Sherwin Williams mid-range options.
2. Why is Benjamin Moore more expensive?
Ans: Higher pigment content, superior coverage, and consistency in premium lines contribute to the higher cost per gallon.
3. Does Sherwin Williams have sales more often?
Ans: Yes, Sherwin Williams frequently offers promotions and discounts, making some of their paints more budget-friendly than Benjamin Moore.
4. Which paint lasts longer – Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams?
Ans: Both brands offer durable paints, but Benjamin Moore’s premium lines generally retain color longer and require fewer touch-ups.
5. Which is better for exterior painting?
Ans: Sherwin Williams’ Duration and Emerald lines perform very well outdoors, while Benjamin Moore’s Aura Exterior is also a top-tier choice.
6. Which paint needs fewer coats?
Ans: Benjamin Moore premium paints usually require fewer coats due to higher coverage, reducing labor and material costs.
7. Is Benjamin Moore worth the extra price?
Ans: For projects prioritizing finish quality and fewer coats, Benjamin Moore is often worth the investment.
8. Which paint is better for DIY beginners?
Ans: Sherwin Williams is more accessible and easier to work with for first-time painters, especially mid-range lines like SuperPaint.